The Unbridgeable Gulf (in which I take generous liberties with the limerick form)There was an inciter named
Sokalwho
laid bare the sins of a
journal.
Whether
for or
againsthis true aim was not sensed;
'twas really an hommage to
Urkel.
* * *
Came across
this today (via
Robot Wisdom), which is serendipitous considering I'd just the other day been reconsidering the Sokal Affair (while reading a lengthy but well considered opinion piece I can't seem to find now). A little more digging unearthed this
account of the new scandal, which closes tantalizingly with the author's admission that he can't disclose some new tidbit of information he's come across.
Seems that while pomo journals sometimes suffer from a lack of understanding of the subject matter they attempt to dissect, the referee process used by physics journals (or
some of them, at any rate) isn't much of a process. More bloggy analysis
here and
here (scroll up to read more commentary).
These things that poke holes in the academic system are a source of endless fascination for me. Whither thou goest, and why? (And perhaps more importantly, why are there so many German-language sites devoted to
Steve Urkel?)
posted by Abbi at 6:40 PM